Column: Drug shortage: What can I do?
Will I be able to eat and drink enough to make
it through the day without passing out? Will the side effects prevent
me from working this week? Will my chances of survival increase if I
have both breasts removed instead of just the one? Will I be here to
celebrate my next birthday?
These are just some of the questions that I and
the hundreds of thousands of others going through cancer treatment
ponder on a daily basis. We know that these questions come with the
territory, and we try to focus on staying positive and getting well.
What we didn't anticipate was the truly life-threatening question we
were hit with this summer — will our doctors be able to get the drugs
we need to survive? As of now, this question remains unanswered.
As the Food and Drug Administration recently acknowledged,
there is a serious shortage of lifesaving intravenous drugs needed to
treat a variety of cancers in the USA. Though not all the drug shortages
are for cancer treatment, the majority are. There are 197 drugs on a shortage list compiled by the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists in Bethesda, Md., a list that includes drugs
that treat breast, ovarian, lung and colon cancers as well as various
forms of leukemia and lymphoma. According to Cynthia Reilly, the
director of ASHP's Practice Development Division, "There are cancer
patients who will die because of this."
Shortage hits home
On May 13, the drug I depend upon was added to the list,
a fact I became aware of the night before my ninth chemotherapy
treatment. I was notified by my oncologist that his facility might not
have any paclitaxel, the intravenous drug I need to cure my cancer. He
told me to come in as planned and we would discuss our options as
necessary. This was worrisome because, as far as I know, I don't have
any options. Paclitaxel, the generic version of the drug Taxol, is the
final part of a three-drug regimen that is the gold standard for
treating the relatively rare type of breast cancer I was diagnosed with
in March.
How could a shortage of such life-and-death drugs happen?
The FDA
reported a record spike in drug shortages in 2010, a trend that
continues this year and appears to be getting worse. A limit placed on
the amount manufacturers can charge for generic drugs led to a
significant drop in their profits. This caused many companies to stop
making the drugs, a decision that served their bottom line but placed
those of us who rely on them in danger.
There
also is no regulatory requirement that manufacturers notify the FDA
when they stop making a drug. So the agency had no idea the production
of these critical drugs had stopped. In turn, this gave the FDA no
opportunity to take action to prevent the shortage from occurring, and
other manufacturers had no way of knowing they had an opportunity to
pick up the slack.
The situation is
exacerbated by the fact that intravenous chemotherapy drugs are very
difficult to make, and their production is subject to strict
quality-control measures. With the void left by the companies that got
out of the business, any quality problems experienced by the remaining
companies that interrupt production have an immediate negative impact on
the overall supply.
A Solomon's decision
My
treatment facility provides chemotherapy to approximately 150 patients
per week. Now, the doctors must spend valuable time holding meetings to
determine which of their patients should get the limited supply of
lifesaving drugs that trickle in each week. Who can receive the drugs
because they have a chance of being cured? Who cannot be cured but can
have their life prolonged for a year or maybe more with the drugs? Which
patients can receive an alternative treatment and survive, and which
cannot?
After a sleepless night, I went in for
my regularly scheduled appointment not knowing whether I would receive
the drug. Based on the protocol the doctors had established, I was told
I would receive one of the doses of paclitaxel they had left. At first,
I felt an overwhelming sense of relief. But my relief was immediately
replaced with guilt and sadness. I couldn't stop wondering, if I am
getting the drug, who isn't?
All over the
country, doctors are faced with these difficult decisions, patients are
worried about the quality of their care and all of us are wondering when
this issue will be resolved.
There are several ongoing efforts to alleviate the problem, including proposed legislation
to require companies to report to the FDA well in advance a decision
to stop manufacturing a drug. The FDA is also considering allowing some
of the drugs to be imported from foreign sources that have not been
approved in the U.S. But the agency, of course, must first ensure that
the drugs meet its quality standards. While it is heartening that these
efforts are underway, all these fixes will take time that many of us
don't have.
What's the latest status on my cancer drug? Bedford Laboratories told ABC News
that it expects to release more paclitaxel soon. But Teva
Pharmaceuticals USA anticipated "constraints through the summer." In
truth, nobody really knows.
So, we add to the
list of questions we worry about on a daily basis: Will I be one of the
"lucky" ones to receive my chemotherapy this week? Do I really deserve
it more than someone else?
